The advice you’d find in a 2020 article about hiring a marketing agency (check their portfolio, make sure the price is right, see if you get along) isn’t wrong. It’s just incomplete. What agencies do and how they do it has changed so much in the last few years that the most important questions to ask weren’t even on the radar back then.
Over 41% of Google searches now trigger AI Overviews. That means your agency needs to understand how to get your business visible inside AI systems, not just traditional search results. The AI marketing sector is projected to grow from $20.44 billion in 2024 to $82.23 billion by 2030, and many agencies have rebranded as “AI-powered” far faster than they’ve actually adapted their capabilities.
What Actually Matters Now
Ask how they use AI, and expect a specific answer. Every agency claims to use AI. The question is whether they can tell you exactly how. Which tools? What’s automated versus human-directed? What percentage of your content or campaign management involves AI, and what gets human review before it goes live? An agency that can’t answer these questions clearly is either not using AI in a meaningful way or doesn’t understand their own processes well enough to manage yours.
Look at outcomes, not activity reports. The old portfolio review still matters, but what you’re looking for has changed. Don’t settle for traffic graphs and follower counts. Ask for before-and-after metrics tied to business results: customer acquisition cost, return on ad spend, lead-to-close rates, revenue attribution. Case studies should tell you what the client’s problem was, what the agency did, and what measurable result it produced. Anything less is marketing, not evidence.
Test their understanding of how search works now. SEO in 2026 isn’t just about ranking on page one. It’s about appearing in AI Overviews, featured snippets, and answer boxes. A capable agency should be talking about structured data, entity-based optimization, and content built for AI citation. Not just keyword density and backlinks. If their SEO pitch sounds the same as it would have in 2019, they haven’t kept up.
The agencies producing the best results right now are also the ones coordinating paid media, organic search, social, email, and content as a unified system. If an agency runs your Google Ads in one department and your social media in another and the two teams never compare notes, you’re paying for fragmentation.
No Fluff · No Long Contracts
Skip the Agency BS.
Get Real Results.
Let’s see if we’re a fit.
Red Flags That Should Stop the Conversation
Some warning signs haven’t changed. Others are new. All of them should make you pause.
No legitimate agency guarantees a specific Google ranking or an AI Overview appearance. These outcomes depend on competition, algorithm changes, and factors outside anyone’s control. Guarantees are either dishonest or come with asterisks that render them meaningless.
You should know exactly what you’re paying for. Strategy, execution, media spend, tools, and platform fees should all be itemized. Hidden markups on ad spend and bundled “management fees” that obscure where your money goes tell you something about how the rest of the relationship will go.
One of the most common agency complaints is that the experienced strategists who sold the engagement hand it off to junior staff after the contract is signed. Ask directly: who will manage your account day-to-day, what’s their experience level, and will you have regular access to senior leadership?
Any agency in 2026 that doesn’t give you direct, real-time access to your campaign data is hiding something. You should be able to see performance metrics anytime, not just in a monthly PDF that the agency curates.
And if the agency is offering identical packages to a local plumber and a national SaaS company, they’re selling templates, not strategy.
Questions to Ask Before You Sign
Skip the generic “tell me about your team” conversation. These are the questions that separate strong agencies from average ones.
What does your reporting include, and how often do I see it? Monthly reporting tied to specific KPIs is the minimum. Weekly check-ins or real-time dashboard access is better. The report should explain what happened, why it happened, and what’s being adjusted.
Who owns the content and data you create for me? This should be spelled out in the contract. If the agency owns your ad accounts, your content, or your analytics setup, you’re locked in whether the relationship works out or not. You should own everything they build on your behalf.
What does your onboarding process look like, and what should I expect in the first 90 days? Strong agencies have a defined onboarding timeline with specific milestones. Vague promises about “ramping up” without concrete benchmarks suggest they don’t have a repeatable process.
How do you handle it when something isn’t working? This tells you more about an agency than their highlight reel. You want an answer that includes proactive testing, honest communication about underperformance, and a clear framework for pivoting. Not finger-pointing at algorithms or market conditions.
The Trust Factor Still Matters
Only 42% of consumers trust businesses to use AI ethically, down from 58% in 2023. That declining trust means your agency’s approach to data governance, privacy compliance, and responsible AI use isn’t abstract. It directly impacts how your customers perceive your brand. Ask about CCPA and GDPR adherence, consent management, and how they handle bias checks on AI-generated content.
The right agency treats your business like a business, not a retainer. They measure their success by your growth, explain their work in language you understand, and adjust when conditions change.
If you’re evaluating agencies or rethinking your current marketing partnership, having a clear strategic framework makes the process faster and the outcome better. That’s the foundation our Digital Strategy service is built on, helping businesses define what they need before they start shopping for who delivers it.
Feeling Overwhelmed by your Marketing?
You don’t have to figure out the tools alone. Tell us where you’re stuck.
Let's Make Marketing Work
Ready to skip the agency BS and get results? We’re taking on new clients who want straight-shooting digital marketing that actually drives growth.
And hey, if you’re in Austin, TX and want to talk strategy over a pint, we’re down for that too.